On behalf of the five Catholic dioceses in the state of Indiana, the Indiana Catholic Conference is strongly opposed to the decision to seek the resumption of executions in Indiana as recently announced by the Indiana Governor and Attorney General.
A Consistent Ethic of Life
The Catholic Church has consistently sought to protect human life from conception to natural death. As Pope Saint John Paul II reminded us in 1999, “the new evangelization calls us to be unconditionally pro-life,” and that “modern society has the means of protecting itself without definitely denying criminals the chance to reform.” More recently, Pope Francis emphasized the Church’s opposition to the death penalty in a change to the Catechism of the Catholic Church: “The death penalty is inadmissible because it is an attack on the inviolability and dignity of the person.” (CCC 2267)
We are grateful for Indiana’s commitment to protecting human life, particularly for the preborn. However, the Church holds that human dignity is also offended when the state’s punishment takes a life. The convicted, the executioner, and society are all harmed when violence is unnecessarily carried out, especially when the penal system can adequately protect the social order from further harm.
Solidarity with Victims
When speaking against the use of the death penalty, the Church is abundantly clear in her expression of solidarity with the family and friends of victims. As the Indiana Catholic Conference expressed in a 2019 letter opposing the end of the federal moratorium on the death penalty: “In seeking to end the use of the death penalty, we do not dismiss the evil and harm caused by people who commit horrible crimes, especially murder. We share in the sorrow and loss of families and victims of such crimes. And we call upon our faith community and all persons of good will to stand with the victims and to provide spiritual, pastoral and personal support.”
Indiana Should Eliminate Use of the Death Penalty
In addition to the Church’s moral teaching, there are several compelling reasons for Indiana to forego the use of the death penalty: 1) there are other means of protecting society and punishing criminals, 2) the death penalty demonstrably does not deter crime, 3) its application is flawed and can be irreversibly wrong, 4) death penalty cases are extremely expensive compared to other criminal cases, and 5) twenty-nine states no longer use it as a form of punishment.
The ICC’s Appeal to the Indiana General Assembly, Governor, and Attorney General
The Indiana Catholic Conference calls upon the Attorney General, members of the Indiana General Assembly, and the Governor, respectively, to:
1) Rescind the motion asking the Indiana Supreme Court to set an execution date for Joseph Corcoran.
2) Legislatively repeal the use of the death penalty in Indiana.
3) Remove plans to include a death chamber in the new state prison under construction in Westville, IN.
These actions would bring Indiana closer to implementing a consistent protection of human life and social order through law. We make this appeal alongside a commitment to working with our elected leaders and public officials to continue strengthening the culture of life in our great state.
February 3, 2023
To: All Priests
CC: Directors of Operations, Directors of Evangelization, Pastorate Communicators
From: Bishop Doherty
Subject: March 17, 2023
Dear Priests,
In the season of Lent, we seek to draw closer to our Lord Jesus. We do so through prayer, fasting and almsgiving. We also practice abstinence from eating meat on all Fridays of Lent, as well as on Ash Wednesday and on Good Friday. The law of abstinence binds all those who have attained the age of fourteen (CIC §1252).
Modeling our lives after missionary saints is also central to our Lenten journey. This year, the Memorial of Saint Patrick takes place on March 17 and coincides with a Lenten Friday. It is a feast day of great importance to the faithful and possesses significant cultural and ethnic importance as well. Therefore, I hereby dispense Catholics in the Diocese of Lafayette-in-Indiana from the obligations of Lenten fast and abstinence for Friday, March 17, 2023 (CIC §85).
Anyone taking advantage of this dispensation from rules that normally apply to them is asked to pick another day in Lent to observe the penitential practices. I also ask that as we enjoy a festive March 17th meal with family and friends, we be mindful of our brothers and sisters in the world who do not have enough to eat. Please consider a donation to one of the many food pantries in the diocese as another fitting way to commemorate the Memorial of Saint Patrick.
We do penance in imitation of Jesus’ fast of 40 days in the desert, eager to draw nearer to him in love.
In Christ’s peace,
Bishop Timothy Doherty
Read the Spanish translation here.
The U.S. Supreme Court ruling in the case of Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization presents a correction for understanding Constitutional process and the proper relation of government branches. The Dobbs decision and overturning Roe v. Wade tells us there is no federal constitutional right to abortion on demand. The states are now left to legislate for or against procuring abortion. Some have already done so. While the Supreme Court’s decision offers an important moment for us to bolster life protections for the unborn, it does not end the public debate. We now need to turn our attention to our Indiana state legislators to urge them to enact or preserve sustainable laws to protect the rights of the unborn.
Read the full statement here. Spanish translation here.
A message from the Diocese of Lafayette-in-Indiana:
On Friday, March 11, Father James De Oreo was suspended from public ministry in the Diocese of Lafayette-in-Indiana. The diocese received allegations of inappropriate conduct with a minor that violates the Essential Norms and the Diocesan Code of Conduct for Clergy. This was reported to Indiana Child Protective Services. A preliminary investigation is ongoing, and precautionary measures are in place according to Canon 1722 of the Code of Canon Law. During the investigation, Father De Oreo should be treated with the presumption of innocence.
If you are aware of any misconduct during Father De Oreo’s ministry as a priest or seminarian, we encourage you to report the incident in the following manner:
1. Make a report to Child Protective Services by calling 800-800-5556 or local law enforcement.
2. Call Jackie Montrie M.A., LMFT, LMHC Victim Assistance Coordinator of the Diocese of Lafayette-in-Indiana at (765) 464-4988.
The safety and wellbeing of our children and young people are of the utmost importance. We all share a commitment to be part of the Church’s mission to respect and protect people of every age. We invite you to join us in prayer for the healing guidance of the Holy Spirit on behalf of all who have been victims of abuse.
Un mensaje de la Diócesis de Lafayette-in-Indiana:
El viernes 11 de marzo, el Padre James De Oreo fue suspendido de su ministerio público en la Diócesis de Lafayette-en-Indiana. La diócesis recibió denuncias de conducta inapropiada con una persona menor de edad que quebrantan las Normas Esenciales y el Código Diocesano de Conducta para el Clero. Esto fue informado a los Servicios de Protección Infantil de Indiana. Se encuentra en curso una investigación preliminar y medidas cautelares según el Canon 1722 del Código de Derecho Canónico. Durante la investigación, el Padre De Oreo debe ser tratado con la presunción de inocencia.
Si tiene conocimiento de alguna mala conducta durante el ministerio del Padre De Oreo como Sacerdote o como Seminarista, lo alentamos a que informe el incidente de la siguiente manera:
1. Haga un informe a los Servicios de Protección Infantil llamando al 800-800-5556 o a la policía local.
2. Llame a Jackie Montrie M.A., LMFT, Coordinadora de Asistencia a Víctimas de LMHC de la Diócesis de Lafayette-en-Indiana al (765) 464-4988.
La seguridad y el bienestar de nuestros niños y de nuestros jóvenes son de suma importancia. Todos compartimos el compromiso de ser parte de la misión de la Iglesia de respetar y proteger a las personas de todas las edades. Les invitamos a unirse a nosotros en oración por la guía sanadora del Espíritu Santo en nombre de todos los que han sido víctimas de abuso.
Bishop Doherty statement on the Vatican “McCarrick Report” to be released at 8:00 AM EST on Tuesday, November 10, 2020.
The question of “when” has been asked by bishops and our people for over a year. I have not seen it, nor any summary of its contents as of November 6. No doubt it will be a black eye for the Church, but it is better to know what went wrong. Sin abhors daylight and healing requires light. Theodore McCarrick was dismissed from the clerical state (defrocked) on February 13, 2019. Those who were victimized by McCarrick may receive some consolation as wrongs done to them are acknowledged. Any who may have warned against McCarrick’s advancement will be vindicated.
I will have more to say about the matter after I read the Vatican report. Media sources say that it is quite lengthy. It is part of my role to read what it will contain, but my ongoing disgust with the McCarrick affair means that I am not looking forward to it. It is difficult to overstate the pain and distress that our priests experience from the shock waves radiating from everything relating to McCarrick’s immoral actions. They need our prayerful support.
It is important for you to know that I had no prior knowledge of McCarrick’s reputation for illicit behavior when it came to his abuses of power or his sexual misdeeds.
As I related a year ago at this time, “When news of McCarrick’s evil actions came to light in June of 2018, many Catholics’ first concern was for the integrity of our seminaries. Seminary administrators immediately set to work examining their institutions and re-stating processes to insure the safety of seminarians. Seminarians and their families deserved and received communications about behavioral expectations and any violations of them. This appeared to be underreported only because there were so many events competing for headlines for the rest of that summer and fall.
“Predating the McCarrick revelations, all diocesan clergy and employees, and all volunteers who have contact with minors, sign a code of conduct as part of their required Safe and Sacred Training.”
In addition, by the Fall of 2019, all of our active priests and deacons, me included, signed our Code of Conduct for Clergy of the Diocese of Lafayette-in-Indiana.
Pointing out all the holy good ministries of the Church at this time might, to some, appear self-serving. But we are well reminded that sin has marred our mission through time, as early as Judas’s betrayal and Peter’s denial. Even so, grace, holiness and nobility have always shown brightly. These require continual recommitment on our part, and I certainly encourage our personal adherence to these things in our present moment.
Download the full statement here.
The nationwide service has been established to receive reports of sexual abuse and related misconduct by bishops for investigation
Lafayette, IN – The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops today announced the Catholic Bishop Abuse Reporting (CBAR) Service has been established to receive reports of sexual abuse and related misconduct by bishops, and to relay those reports to proper authorities for investigation. This is the latest measure from Pope Francis’ apostolic letter, Vos estis lux mundi (“You are the light of the world”) to be implemented.
Read more here...
February 12, 2020
WASHINGTON—Archbishop José H. Gomez of Los Angeles and president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, has issued the following statement regarding the release today of Pope Francis’s Post-Synodal Apostolic Exhortation, Querida Amazonia. The exhortation follows upon the Special Synod of Bishops held in Rome from October 6-27, 2019 that focused on the Amazon region.
Archbishop Gomez’s statement follows:
“Today our Holy Father Pope Francis offers us a hopeful and challenging vision of the future of the Amazon region, one of the earth’s most sensitive and crucial ecosystems, and home to a rich diversity of cultures and peoples. The Pope reminds us that the Church serves humanity by proclaiming Jesus Christ and his Gospel of love, and he calls for an evangelization that respects the identities and histories of the Amazonian peoples and that is open to the ‘novelty of the Spirit, who is always able to create something new with the inexhaustible riches of Jesus Christ.’
“He also calls all of us in the Americas and throughout the West to examine our ‘style of life’ and to reflect on the consequences that our decisions have for the environment and for the poor. Along with my brother bishops here in the United States, I am grateful for the Holy Father’s wisdom and guidance and we pledge our continued commitment to evangelizing and building a world that is more just and fraternal and that respects the integrity of God’s creation.”
---
Media Contacts
Chieko Noguchi or Miguel Guilarte
(202) 541-3200
March 2020:
Ongoing Coronavirus (COVID-19) Communcations
February 2020:
President of USCCB Issues Statement on Pope Francis’ Apostolic Exhortation, Querida Amazonia
May 2019:
New norms for the whole Church against those who abuse or cover up
February 2019:
Meeting on the Protection of Minors in the Church
October 2018:
Primer on Recent News Accounts of the Abuse of Minors
September 2018:
Priests who served in the Diocese of Lafayette-in-Indiana with Substantiated Allegations of Sexual Misconduct with Minors
U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops' Administrative Committee Statement on Sex Abuse Scandals
Bishop Doherty's Statement from Sept. 16, 2018 edition of the Catholic Moment
Diocese of Fort Wayne-South Bend releases statement regarding conclusion of DA investigation
Conversation with Cardinal Dolan: September 11, 2018
Bishop Doherty's Message in The Catholic Moment: Sept. 3, 2018
August 2018:
Archbishop McCarrick; the Pennsylvania Report, August 5, 2018
Joint Response to Pennsylvania Grand Jury
President of U.S. Bishops' Conference Announces Effort, August 16, 2018
Bishop Doherty's Message to the Diocese: August 16, 2018
Letter of His Holiness Pope Francis to the People of God, August 20, 2018
Watch Bishop Doherty on CNN, August 17, 2018
President of U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops Renews Commitment